Practice Operations

Who Owns the No? The Six Cuts Under a Treatment Acceptance Rate


James DeLuca 11 min read

Ask an owner for their case acceptance rate and you will get one number. Ask a better-run practice and you will get two: acceptance and completion. Both are real. Both are the tip of a pyramid, and a practice that manages the tip is managing the one number in the building that cannot tell anyone what to do next.

Here are two practices. The first is a $10 million, multi-provider practice whose treatment planner shows 24% of diagnosed treatment accepted. The second is a two-doctor practice whose coordinators log every presentation by hand, and 73% of the plans they present are accepted in full. One headline says the practice is broken. The other says there is nothing to fix. Both headlines are wrong about where the work is, and the same row in each practice’s ledger proves it.

What follows is the pyramid under the rate: six cuts, each with an owner, and the row that shows why the headline was never going to find the leak.

The number your dashboard gives you

Accepted dollars over presented dollars, trailing twelve months, every provider and every procedure in one fraction. The institutional target is 75% of treatment dollars presented either completed or accepted; the median practice sits near 55%, and most owners believe they are near 80% because the software counts only the patients the team marked as a yes to something.

It is a fair number for what it measures, which is the practice’s overall conversion of diagnosis into scheduled care. What it cannot do is assign the no to anyone. The dentist reads 48% and hears the front desk. The financial coordinator reads it and hears the diagnosis. The hygienist is not in the conversation at all, and in the first practice below she presented a fifth of the dollars.

Cut one: by provider, including hygiene

The first cut is the one every owner thinks they already run, and almost none run all the way down.

In the $10 million practice, the owner performed 4.4% of the exams and originated 24.6% of the diagnosis, which The Point Guard covered. Here is what happened to that diagnosis. He proposed $5.1 million of treatment and 9.5% of it was accepted. His average plan was $10,600. The associates’ plans averaged $900 to $1,400 and accepted at 23% to 41%.

Then the rows most provider reports never print. Treatment diagnosed in a recall chair carries the hygienist’s name alongside the dentist’s, and in this practice $7.7 million, a fifth of everything presented, came through hygiene. What their row shows is variance. Across seven hygienists with half a million dollars or more attached, acceptance ran from 31% to 41%, on the same dentists presenting the same procedures. Ten points between chairs is not the dentist. It is what happened in the twenty minutes before they walked in.

One hygienist sees the crowding, tells the patient the doctor will probably want to talk about it, and lets the doctor confirm and present it. Another sees it and says nothing; the doctor presents cold, and the patient gets the price before they have heard what they are getting for it. The variance between those two chairs is where a practice finds the best practice it can prove works on its own patients, because the top chair is already doing it.

Who owns this no: the person presenting, and the hygienist who did or did not set it up.

Cut two: by exam type

The three exam codes are three different patients, and the practice has a different amount of goodwill with each one.

The comprehensive exam is the new patient. They may or may not see a hygienist on the first visit, they are hearing the plan for the first time, and the practice has no relationship to spend. Whatever accepts here accepts on the strength of the presentation alone.

The periodic exam is the returning patient, primarily in the hygiene chair. Two things happen in it. Unscheduled treatment from the last visit is revisited, so the patient is hearing it for the second or third time, and new conditions are added. There is goodwill in this chair that the comprehensive exam never had, which is why a practice’s periodic acceptance should run ahead of its comprehensive acceptance, and it is a finding when it does not.

The limited exam is the problem-focused visit. It usually converts higher than either of the others, because the patient has a need that day and accepts the tooth that hurts. It is also the leakiest chair in the building, because it closes the issue instead of opening into a comprehensive exam. The emergency patient who is fixed and released is a patient the practice will see again when the next tooth hurts, and not before. The conversion rate on the limited exam looks excellent and the conversion of the limited exam into a comprehensive one is the number nobody reports.

Blend the three and the limited exams prop up the rate while the comprehensive exams pull it down, and none of the three chairs learns anything. Cut them apart and the practice can see whether its goodwill is converting, whether its first impression is, and how many of its emergencies became patients.

Who owns this no: the exam protocol, and whoever decides what happens after the emergency is handled.

Cut three: by CDT group

The clinical team does not think in dollars. It thinks in procedures, and the CDT grouping is the cut it can act on. The $10 million practice again, eight treatment families, with the exams, radiographs and prophylaxis that nobody declines set aside:

GroupPresentedAccepted
Fillings$2.29M41.5%
Perio$4.48M36.8%
Endo$1.25M33.6%
Extractions$2.53M28.1%
Crowns$1.12M26.1%
Prosthetics$0.34M15.3%
Ortho and aligners$6.15M13.5%
Implants$4.32M9.1%

Fillings accept at four and a half times the rate of implants. Implants and ortho are 47% of everything presented and convert at 11.7% between them: ten and a half million dollars of diagnosed treatment, and a little more than one dollar in nine accepted.

Who owns this no: clinical education, materials, and whether a family has a consult path or is mentioned on the way out the door.

The row that turns the article: 14% ortho

Now the second practice. Its headline is 73% of plans accepted in full, 61% of presented dollars over ten months. Nothing to fix. Like the first practice, its ortho row also reads 14%.

So I asked the owner about the discrepancy. He does not like doing ortho. He is selective about the cases he takes and he does not bring it up; the aligner cases in his log are mostly patients who asked. His 14% is a decision, made by the doctor, on purpose. The fix is nothing, or a referral relationship. The row is an opportunity, not a leak.

The first practice’s ortho row reads 13.5%, on $6.15 million presented. Nobody presents six million dollars of anything by accident. That row is an operational breakdown. An aligner case has its own economics and its own monthly-payment conversation, and in most practices with ortho integrated, its own financing channel. The first practice ran everyone through the same single prime lender and the same checkout window as a $20,000 implant case. Then the utilization: this practice collected 5.9% of its revenue through third-party financing, against a standard of 15% or more, and 89% of its patient payments ran on a credit card. One number, 14%, in two practices. A decision in one and $5.3 million a year of the operation’s own making in the other.

Neither headline would have surfaced the row. The 73% practice had no reason to look. The 24% practice had too many reasons, and no way to choose among them. The cut forced a conversation in one practice and found a leak in the other, and that is what the cuts are for.

Cut four: by dollar band

The coordinator and the patient do not experience a CDT code. They experience a number on an estimate, and the band cut is the one that belongs to the financial side of the practice. The second practice’s log, ten months, 445 presentations:

Plan sizePresentationsPresentedAcceptedWhole plan acceptedHygiene booked at presentation
Under $1,000136$72K93%84%82%
$1,000 to $3,000155$342K82%81%84%
$3,000 to $5,00058$239K78%76%79%
$5,000 to $10,00069$498K49%48%72%
$10,000 and up27$489K45%33%74%
All445$1.64M61%73%80%

The cliff is at $5,000. Below it, three bands in the high seventies to the low nineties. Above it, half. Same doctors, same coordinators, same ten months. The 73% headline is true, and it is made of a 93% band and a 45% band that have nothing in common.

This practice has every financing instrument the first practice lacks: prime, sub-prime, a big-ticket lender, a credit union. It submitted four financing applications this year. Four, against 96 presentations over $5,000, of which roughly $520,000 was declined. The practice sits in a well-off area, the team assumes its patients do not need help paying, and so it mentions financing to almost no one. The stack is on the wall and the habit does not exist.

That is why the band cut does not simply hand the no to the coordinator, and why effort has to be measured separately from the instruments. A lender nobody offers is the same as no lender. Above $10,000 only one patient in three accepted the whole plan; the rest took a piece of it, and a patient who takes a piece of a $12,000 plan is usually a patient who was never asked how they would like to pay for the whole one.

Who owns this no: the financial coordinator, and the conversation they did or did not have. The instruments exist. Above $5,000 the no is effort.

Cut five: financing utilization

Third-party financing is measured twice, and most practices measure it never. Effort is applications submitted per presentation above a threshold, say $500; it lives in the lender’s portal, not the practice software. The second practice’s answer was four for the year, against 96 plans over $5,000. The first practice could not produce the number at all. Effectiveness is dollars collected through financing as a share of revenue, and the standard is 15% or more. The $10 million practice: $600,000, 5.9%.

Underneath both numbers is the stack, which is a checklist rather than a rate:

InstrumentCoversThe $10M practiceThe two-doctor practice
Prime lenderPlans under $10,000YesYes
Sub-prime lenderPlans under $10,000 that prime declinesNoYes
Big-ticket lenderFull-arch, implant and comprehensive cases to $100,000NoYes
Local credit unionSecured loans for patients who prefer a bankNoYes
Applications submitted this yearEffortNot produced4

A band with no instrument behind it does not have an acceptance rate. It has a ceiling. The 9% on implants in the first practice is not a performance that training will move; it is what a $20,000 case converts at when the only option on the counter is a credit card. And a band with four instruments and four applications has the same ceiling, reached from the other direction.

Who owns this no: the owner, for whether the instruments exist, and the coordinator, for whether anyone is offered them. The second practice is the proof that the first is not enough.

Cut six: the durability of the yes

A scheduled case with no money down is a maybe on the schedule. The same-day deposit rate by band is the durability of the yes, and it sits upstream of the broken appointment rate the practice will complain about in six weeks. The second practice’s log carries a cousin of it: whether hygiene was booked before the patient left, which ran between 72% and 84% across the bands. The patient who leaves with the next visit booked is the patient who comes back to start the plan. And whole-plan acceptance against partial acceptance, by band, is the last durability read: a plan accepted in pieces is a plan that will be re-presented, and re-presented plans decay.

Who owns this no: the checkout, and the scheduling system behind it.

The denominator, before any of it

None of the six cuts means anything until two definitions hold.

Accepted is treatment that was completed, scheduled, or marked accepted in the software. All three count.

Presented, and the calculation between the two, is where every analytics dashboard I have read gets it wrong, in two common directions at once. Treatment added straight to the appointment without passing through the treatment planner enters the numerator and never touched the denominator; the rate goes up, or the treatment never gets counted at all. Two plans on one tooth that were never reconciled when the patient chose one leave both in the denominator; the rate goes down. The Dashboard Charade walks through the second error and the watch-and-wait diagnoses that never get entered at all. The two errors cancel in the headline and compound in every cut, which is how a practice reports 94% acceptance on a $320 average presentation and believes it.

It is also why the two practices above are not comparable to each other. The first practice’s 24% is every line in a planner that nobody reconciles. The second practice’s 73% is a person writing down what was actually presented, which is a reconciled denominator by construction. The second practice did not have better patients. It had a system built to collect the data, instead of one that collects it as a side effect of billing.

Why a buyer reads it this way

A buyer’s diligence team does not price a blended rate. It prices unscheduled treatment by band and by family, because the big bands are where the seller’s claimed upside lives and the big families are where a payer’s auditor will look. The doctor-to-doctor evaluation in The Audit Comes Either Way carried $1.19 million of unscheduled treatment that the practice itself flagged as inaccurate, and nobody on either side could say which band it sat in or how much of it was duplicate plans. That number was not an asset in the negotiation. It was a question the seller could not answer about his own practice.

How to read your own practice

Reconcile the denominator first. Then six cuts, each with a name next to it.

  1. By provider, including hygiene. Dentists: presented and accepted dollars, average plan size. Hygienists: acceptance on treatment diagnosed in their chair, read as variance between chairs rather than credit. Owner: the presenter, and the chair that set the presentation up.
  2. By exam type. Comprehensive (the new patient, no goodwill yet), periodic (the returning patient, hearing unscheduled treatment a second or third time), limited (the problem visit that converts high and rarely opens into a comprehensive exam). Owner: the exam protocol, and what happens after the emergency.
  3. By CDT group. Eight families plus a group for custom and internal codes. Owner: clinical education, materials, the consult path.
  4. By dollar band. Under $1,000, $1,000 to $3,000, $3,000 to $5,000, $5,000 to $10,000, $10,000 and up. Owner: the financial coordinator, and whether financing was offered on every plan over the threshold.
  5. Financing utilization. Applications per presentation over $500 from the lender’s portal; third-party collections as a share of revenue, 15% or more; the four-instrument checklist. Owner: the owner for the instruments, the coordinator for the applications.
  6. Durability of the yes. Same-day deposits by band, next visit booked at presentation, whole-plan against partial acceptance. Owner: the checkout.

Then take any row that surprises you to the person who owns it and ask. In one of the practices above, that conversation ended the inquiry. In the other, it opened a $5.3 million one.

The bottom line

Case acceptance and case completion rates are the tip of the pyramid. They tell you the practice converts diagnosis into care at some rate, and nothing else. The situational reads underneath them, by provider, by exam, by family, by band, by instrument, by durability, are what expose a systemic leak, because each one has an owner and the blend has none. Nobody owns a blended number. Cut it until someone does.


The by-code and by-provider cuts are in a report every practice can run today: production by procedure code, by provider, trailing twelve months. The full read, with the dollar figure on every gap, is the Baseline Read, and what it finds is on What We Find.


About the author: James DeLuca is the founder of Precision Dental Analytics. He rebuilds the reports a practice’s software produces from the detail underneath them and puts a dollar figure on every gap, for owners who are staying, buying, or selling. He is the author of Phantom EBITDA, The Dental Data Playbook, Hidden Levers, and Spartan Leadership. Meet the team

Questions

Why is a blended case acceptance rate not enough to manage a practice?
Because it has no owner. The rate is a blend of every provider, exam type, procedure family and plan size in the practice, and the reason a patient says no is different in each of them. A $10 million practice reporting 24% and a two-doctor practice reporting 73% both carried a 14% ortho row, for opposite reasons: a deliberate choice by the doctor in one, a missing financing channel in the other. The headline could not tell either owner which practice they were. The cuts underneath it could.
Why measure treatment acceptance by provider, including hygienists?
Because the hygienist cannot diagnose but she sets up the diagnosis, and the variance between hygiene chairs is where a practice finds the presentation habit it can prove works. In a $10 million practice, $7.7 million of treatment, a fifth of everything presented, was diagnosed in recall chairs; across seven hygienists with half a million dollars or more attached, acceptance ran from 31% to 41% on the same dentists presenting the same procedures. The dentist cut matters too: the owner, with 4.4% of exams, 24.6% of diagnosis and a $10,600 average plan, converted 9.5% while the associates ran 23% to 41%.
Why does treatment acceptance fall as the case size rises?
Because the reason a patient says no changes with the dollar amount, and most practices have an answer for only the first reason. Under $1,000 the no is a scheduling failure. Between $1,000 and $5,000 it is the financial conversation. Above $5,000 it is whether anyone offered the patient a way to pay. In a practice that logs every presentation by hand, acceptance ran 93%, 82% and 78% in the three bands under $5,000 and 49% and 45% in the two bands above it, with the same doctors and coordinators; the practice had four lenders available and submitted four applications in the year.
What should third-party financing be as a share of collections?
Fifteen percent or more of revenue collected through third-party patient financing, which measures effectiveness. Effort is measured separately as applications submitted per presentation above a threshold such as $500, and it comes from the lender's portal because the practice software does not record it. A $10 million practice with one prime lender collected 5.9% through financing and ran 89% of patient payments on credit cards; its implant acceptance was 9%.
What is the minimum patient financing stack for a dental practice?
Four instruments, and they are a checklist rather than a rate: a prime lender for plans under $10,000; a sub-prime lender for plans under $10,000 that prime declines; a big-ticket lender that reaches $50,000 to $100,000 for full-arch, implant and comprehensive cases; and a relationship with a local credit union for secured loans. A dollar band with no instrument behind it has a ceiling, not an acceptance rate, and the instruments only count if they are offered: one practice with all four submitted four applications in ten months.
Why is the presented treatment number wrong on most dashboards?
Two recording errors, pushing in opposite directions. Treatment added straight to an appointment without passing through the treatment planner enters the numerator and skips the denominator, which inflates the rate. Two plans on one tooth that were never reconciled when the patient chose one leave both in the denominator, which deflates it. The errors cancel in the headline and compound in every cut, so the denominator has to be reconciled before any rate by provider, code or band means anything.

Put a number on what this article describes.

The Baseline Read: twelve months of your practice software, each stage of the patient journey scored against a benchmark, and a dollar figure on every gap.

See what it finds →

$2,000, fixed fee | ten business days

James DeLuca

James DeLuca

Founder & Principal Architect, Precision Dental Analytics

About the team →

Put a number on what this article describes.

Twelve months of your practice software across nine stages of the patient journey, each scored against a benchmark. Every gap comes back with a dollar figure on it and a twelve-month order of work.